Untaxed crypto gains? Limitation periods and the threatened abolition of voluntary disclosure

A common and serious mistake with untaxed crypto gains concerns when the period starts: if you do not file a tax return, the criminal limitation period begins to run only in the year after the omission. For tax assessment, the three-year deferral of the start of the period pushes the start back even further, so the risk remains acute for more than a decade.

Attorney Ruhlmann (specialist tax lawyer)

2017 and 2021 were exceptionally high-turnover years for crypto investors. Not all gains made at the time were declared in full. Anyone now considering a supplementary return, or a voluntary disclosure that exempts from punishment under Section 371 of the German Fiscal Code (AO), faces two closely linked questions: how far back does the limitation period reach, and for how much longer will voluntary disclosure exist as an instrument?

Criminal limitation: 5 years, 10 years or 15 years?

The starting point is the criminal limitation period for prosecution, normally five years (Section 78(3) no. 4 of the Criminal Code (StGB) in conjunction with Section 369(2) AO). Many investors rely on this, often too soon. Even with the five-year standard period, there is an absolute upper limit of ten years (Section 78c(3) sentence 2 StGB). Acts that interrupt the period, such as the opening of an investigation, restart it, but only up to a maximum of twice the standard period.

If the tax evaded per offence exceeds €50,000 (the tax, not the gain made), a particularly serious case under Section 370(3) sentence 2 no. 1 AO may be considered (Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 27 October 2015 – 1 StR 373/15). The limitation period is then 15 years (Section 376(1) AO), and the absolute limit is 2.5 times that, i.e. 37.5 years (Section 376(3) AO).

Limitation of tax assessment: runs independently

Even if criminal prosecution is time-barred, the tax office can still claim additional tax. In cases of tax evasion, the assessment period is ten years (Section 169(2) sentence 2 AO). Because the start of the period is deferred under Section 170(2) no. 1 AO, up to 13 years can matter in practice.

Anyone who can still be challenged for tax purposes should therefore not look only at the criminal side. The risk of discovery is also rising: the tax authorities can send collective information requests to crypto exchanges (Section 93(1a) AO), and the Federal Ministry of Finance circular of 6 March 2025 on the income tax treatment of crypto assets has considerably extended investors' duties to cooperate.

Voluntary disclosure under Section 371 AO: a way back, but for how long?

Anyone who wants to regularise crypto gains that have not been declared so far can do so by a voluntary disclosure that exempts from punishment under Section 371 AO, provided no bar applies, such as an investigation that is already under way. The voluntary disclosure must be complete: it covers all tax offences of the tax type concerned that are not time-barred. The limitation calculation therefore directly determines how far the duty to file a supplementary declaration extends.

The abolition of voluntary disclosure that exempts from punishment under Section 371 AO is currently being discussed politically; so far, however, no concrete change in the law has been decided. An abolition would not create a new criminal offence, but would remove the possibility of obtaining impunity through an effective voluntary disclosure. The issue is therefore not the prohibition of retroactive criminal laws in Article 103(2) of the Basic Law but, above all, the protection of legitimate expectations under the rule of law in Article 20(3) of the Basic Law (Federal Constitutional Court, decision of 15 October 2004 – 2 BvR 1316/04). Whether this requires a transitional rule as a matter of constitutional law is an open question. Section 24 of the Introductory Act to the Fiscal Code (EGAO) from 2011 shows that the legislator can provide for transitional provisions, but is not necessarily obliged to. Consequently, merely intending or preparing a voluntary disclosure in case the law changes later does not yet create a secure legal position.

KANZLEI RUHLMANN in Berlin, with its expertise in tax law and tax criminal law, will gladly help at short notice with the assessment and, where appropriate, with further communication with the authorities.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. It does not replace individual legal advice.