Subsidy fraud and COVID aid – defending against confiscation of the full amount

Even years after COVID aid was paid out, many companies now face follow-up proceedings by public prosecutors and tax authorities. A central and often existence-threatening point of dispute in these investigations is the amount of the criminal confiscation. Prosecutors rely on the gross principle and regularly demand repayment of the entire grant received on an application, even if only a small part of it is challenged.

For an applicant who, for example, received a grant of €150,000 and is accused of errors in only one item of €15,000, this practice means disproportionate hardship. A demand for the full €150,000 can endanger the economic substance of a company that often rightly needed the aid to survive in a historic exceptional situation.

In this situation, legal representation can pursue various lines of defence against the threatened gross confiscation. One is to argue that the subsidy application is not an inseparable unit. This can be shown by a detailed breakdown of the items in the application, with the individual statements that can be separated factually and arithmetically proved by business records and the underlying calculations. It may also be possible to challenge the blanket assumption of “unreliability”, provided the application was otherwise made properly and the funds were demonstrably used properly.

On the basis of these and further approaches, negotiations with the public prosecutor's office can be sought, with the aim of discontinuing the proceedings under Section 153a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO) against payment of only the part that was actually challenged.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. It does not replace individual legal advice. I am happy to answer questions about your specific situation.