Shareholder struck from the shareholder list: interim relief against compulsory redemption and exclusion
Losing your voting rights through a manipulated shareholder list is so dangerous because it can create faits accomplis: anyone who no longer has a vote can prevent neither his own exclusion nor the sale of shares in the company.
Fellow shareholders who run the company often try to sideline an unwelcome shareholder at top speed in this way. A mere objection in the commercial register cannot reliably protect him; only an interim injunction can.
Attorney Ruhlmann
Being struck from the shareholder list: a danger for minority shareholders
In shareholder disputes it happens again and again: majority shareholders resolve the compulsory redemption or exclusion of an unwelcome fellow shareholder and immediately file an amended shareholder list with the commercial register in which the person concerned no longer appears. Once the new list is entered, the shareholder loses his status as a shareholder as against the company, even if the exclusion is unlawful (Federal Court of Justice, II ZR 211/19).
Federal Court of Justice II ZR 406/17: protection against secret filing of the list
In an important decision from 2019 (II ZR 406/17, BGHZ 223, 311), the Federal Court of Justice clarified that the company cannot rely on the formal legitimising effect of the shareholder list if it files an amended list in breach of a court prohibition. This applies in particular if the shareholders' meeting was not properly convened and the list was filed secretly without the person concerned being heard. More recent case law of the higher regional courts goes further still: the Higher Regional Court of Munich (decision of 18 May 2021 – 7 W 718/21) and the Higher Regional Court of Hamm (decision of 20 June 2024 – 8 W 10/24) have in such cases even ordered the company to re-file the original shareholder list.
Interim injunction: requirements and means of protection
The shareholder concerned can apply in interim proceedings for an injunction prohibiting the company from filing an amended list. The company can also be ordered to treat him as a shareholder until the main proceedings have been decided. A ground for an injunction already exists if the redemption is more likely than not to be unlawful and there is a danger that the share will be devalued by measures that change the articles or the structure of the company.
Acting quickly: what affected shareholders must do
Quick action is crucial for those affected. As soon as you learn of a planned exclusion or redemption, you should seek legal advice without delay. Interim relief must be applied for in good time, before the list is filed. If the list has already been filed, then in addition to the application to continue to be treated as a shareholder, you should also apply for an objection to the shareholder list to be entered. Claims for damages against the managing directors for breach of their duties of care should also be examined.
Conclusion
Striking a shareholder from the shareholder list is an effective but risky instrument in a shareholder dispute. Case law grants effective protection through interim relief, especially where the company circumvents court orders. Anyone affected by such conduct should not hesitate to seek legal help in order to avert irreversible disadvantages.
Additional practical note
An excluded shareholder should not let ongoing negotiations about an “orderly exit with compensation” deter him from applying for interim relief. If he nevertheless refrains from doing so because of specific assurances from the company that it will stand still, a more recent decision of the Higher Regional Court of Brandenburg (decision of 17 July 2026 – 7 U 107/25) offers at least an emergency anchor in the form of the objection of bad faith.
Attorney Ruhlmann
KANZLEI RUHLMANN in Berlin, as a litigation firm in commercial and company law, supports the enforcement and defence of time-critical interim injunctions in court. It also provides strategic support in the ongoing conflict, in order to secure participation rights and control options in the company for the long term.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. It does not replace individual legal advice.