Fleeing into personal insolvency in cases of tax evasion – are tax debts really discharged?
“Where tax debts are high, the criminal proceedings decide whether residual debts are discharged: only a discontinuation protects against the lifelong debt trap of Section 302 of the Insolvency Code. But this is where the practical dilemma lies: the tax authorities usually demand compensation for the damage as the condition for a discontinuation, a hurdle that insolvent debtors cannot overcome without a strategic defence.”
Attorney Ruhlmann (specialist tax lawyer)
In investigations for tax evasion, considerable tax debts often arise alongside the criminal consequences. Personal insolvency aimed at a discharge of residual debts after three years often seems like a way out.
The bar to discharge: a final criminal judgment
But tax debts, interest and late-payment surcharges remain after a final conviction for a tax offence such as tax evasion and are not wiped out by the discharge of residual debts in insolvency proceedings (cf. Section 302(1) third alternative of the Insolvency Code (InsO)). Deletion from the Federal Central Criminal Register does not change this either. The decisive question is whether a final judgment exists by the time of the discharge. If the conviction comes only after the insolvency proceedings have ended, the discharge applies instead and the old tax debts are treated as settled.
Registration by the tax office, and the possibility of objecting in the insolvency proceedings
In insolvency proceedings, the tax office must expressly register tax debts arising from tax offences with a reference to the offence (so-called attribute registration, Section 174(2) InsO). Only if this addition is made at registration can the claims later be excluded from the discharge under Section 302(1) third alternative InsO. An ordinary registration without this note is not enough. An objection can be lodged against an attribute registration until the decision on the discharge.
If a final criminal judgment is reached despite the objection, the tax office must prove this to the insolvency court or the insolvency administrator by a declaratory notice under Section 251(3) of the Fiscal Code (AO). Only when this notice exists, and the attribute registration has been supplemented or established accordingly, does the tax claim count as “insolvency-proof” and can it still be enforced after the insolvency proceedings have ended. If no declaratory notice is submitted, or if the objection stands, the tax debts are covered by the discharge despite the criminal judgment.
Whether the tax debt can still be enforced after the insolvency therefore depends on how the tax office proceeds and on the outcome of the objection.
Discontinuation of proceedings as a way out?
A discontinuation of the criminal proceedings under Section 153 or 153a of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO) is often seen as a way of avoiding a final conviction. For a discontinuation under Section 153a StPO, however, it is normally required that all outstanding taxes be paid in full. Merely registering the tax debt in the insolvency proceedings is not enough; payment must actually be made. Fines and monetary conditions, in particular those under Section 153a StPO, remain in place despite insolvency under Section 302 no. 2 InsO and are still enforceable.
Conditions that have already been paid can also be reclaimed by the insolvency administrator under the rules on avoidance, which is a risk even though the discontinuation itself stands. In practice, those affected remain unsure whether, after personal insolvency, a substitute custodial sentence can still be imposed and enforced for unpaid fines.
A race between the criminal proceedings and the discharge
In practice, people often ask whether it makes sense to delay the criminal proceedings so as to obtain the discharge before a possible conviction. This strategy is not reliable: only a final conviction that occurs before the end of the insolvency proceedings prevents the discharge under Section 302 InsO. In other words, if the judgment comes later, the discharge stands. In most cases, though, the criminal proceedings can be concluded within the three-year period (the so-called good-conduct phase).
At the end of the insolvency proceedings, the tax office can also try to prevent the discharge under Section 290 InsO, in particular in cases of incomplete information, acts to the detriment of creditors or lack of cooperation.
Conclusion: what decides the fate of tax debts in insolvency proceedings?
“Fleeing” into personal insolvency offers no reliable guarantee of being freed completely from tax debts and fines in cases of tax evasion. What remains decisive is whether a final conviction for a tax offence occurs by the time the discharge is decided. The decision on the discharge depends largely on whether the tax office makes a correct attribute registration and on how the objection proceedings are conducted.
Information and documents in the insolvency proceedings must also always be submitted completely and on time, to avoid giving grounds for refusal under Section 290 InsO.
KANZLEI RUHLMANN in Berlin, as a litigation firm in insolvency law, supports the assessment and examination of such time-critical scenarios and the strategic coordination ahead of insolvency proceedings.
At the same time, thanks to its specialisation in tax disputes and tax criminal law, it provides targeted defence in the investigation proceedings, so that the tax proceedings can be tactically coordinated as well as possible with the course of the insolvency.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. It does not replace individual legal advice.