NRW purchase of offshore account data – when a voluntary disclosure is still in time

The state of North Rhine-Westphalia has, by its own account, acquired a large offshore data set containing customer information from typical offshore centres. Experience shows that such information is evaluated across borders and passed on to the competent authorities. For those affected, this means that the window for an effective voluntary disclosure can close quickly.

Attorney Ruhlmann

The mere purchase of a data CD does not automatically bar a voluntary disclosure. Discovery can be assumed only once a tax authority – not necessarily the locally competent one – has learned of a suspiciously concealed source of tax. This means that anyone who acts before such a reliable state of knowledge exists can secure exemption from punishment.

Case law makes this tangible: in a case involving payments via a Cypriot company to Swiss accounts, the Federal Court of Justice found that the offence had already been discovered by Greek investigators, because account statements and records were available there and, given the media interest and the scale of the case, transmission to Germany was to be expected. The voluntary disclosure filed later was therefore ineffective in that respect. Conversely, the Federal Court of Justice has also clarified that discovery by third parties bars a disclosure only if it has to be expected that the information will be passed on to the competent authority (Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 9 May 2017 – 1 StR 265/16).

Important for timing: in the case of continuing offences, a voluntary disclosure can still bring impunity for the individual acts that have not yet been discovered, even though parts of the offence have already been discovered. Case law has also recognised that a prompt, viable disclosure with reliable estimates can suffice if the tax office can supplement it without particular difficulty, so you can act in time even if not every detail is available yet.

My support from a single source

I examine in confidence whether, in your case, the offence is already to be regarded as discovered or whether a window for an effective voluntary disclosure still exists. Where appropriate, I prepare a timely and viable supplementary declaration – first with reliable estimates if necessary. If the voluntary disclosure is already barred, I represent you in dealings with the tax office, the fines and criminal matters office, the tax investigation unit and the public prosecutor's office, including support with requests for information and searches. The aim is to create legal certainty quickly and to minimise the risks.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. It does not replace individual legal advice. I am happy to answer questions about your specific situation.