Federal Fiscal Court sets limits on flat-rate tax estimates (using standard rates)
The Federal Fiscal Court's new line of case law offers an interesting approach for tax defence work: where an estimate gets completely out of hand for lack of data, the question arises whether the official collection of standard rates (Richtsatzsammlung) can serve as a shield. The table values used to be the tax office's sharpest weapon for extrapolating profits; downgraded by the Federal Fiscal Court, the collection now offers a legal lever for capping implausible estimates.
Attorney Ruhlmann (specialist tax lawyer)
Cash-intensive small businesses such as taxi companies, car dealers, restaurateurs, bakeries, butchers, hairdressing salons and pharmacies are particularly affected: as soon as the bookkeeping shows noticeable gaps, the tax office can estimate the tax base, and the results vary considerably depending on the state of the documentation. The tax office can determine the tax base either by an internal business comparison (a recalculation from the business's own data) or by an external business comparison (an estimate using external comparative values). Which method is used depends on the availability and quality of the business records.
In its judgment of 18 June 2025 (X R 19/21), the Federal Fiscal Court (BFH) clarified the relationship between the internal and external business comparison in a ground-breaking way: the internal business comparison takes priority, that is, a recalculation close to the business based on its own data such as cost of goods, prices and comprehensible deductions. The external business comparison, and in particular the so-called standard-rate estimate, remains admissible but is classed as a subordinate method with considerable uncertainty, and it must be justified more strictly. At the same time, the Federal Fiscal Court expresses considerable doubts about whether the tax administration's official collection of standard rates is statistically suitable in its current form.
In the case decided, a nightclub kept its cash registers open without sufficient individual records. The tax court then used an external comparison with a flat gross-profit mark-up rate from the hospitality sector, although the tax auditor had already begun a recalculation from the cost-of-goods data. The Federal Fiscal Court set this decision aside, because comparability had not been justified and a recalculation from the available business data would have been the obvious and preferable course. The senate thereby sends a clear signal: the more individual and close to the business the data, the more realistic and legally sound the estimate.
Looking ahead, it is to be expected that, in light of this decision, tax audits in cash-intensive sectors will work more often with recalculations close to the business and use external standard rates only exceptionally and with strict justification. For businesses that document well, this is an opportunity: the cleaner the cash register, cost of goods and deductions are documented, the lower the risk of excessive estimated additions. For businesses with gaps in their documentation, on the other hand, there is a growing risk that a recalculation based on inflated cost of goods will lead to high estimated profits, or that, for lack of internal data, imprecise external comparisons will be applied.
For a realistic recalculation, a reliable internal data basis is central: a daily cash record that allows cash to be counted, with counting records and a comprehensible cash balance, regular stocktaking and meaningful consumption and inventory reports by category. Product and service standards (such as recipes and quantities) should be recorded in writing; discounts, giveaways, own consumption and losses should be documented with receipts or records. Complete incoming receipts, cleanly allocated to product groups, and recorded returns and credit notes avoid artificially high consumption figures, and recording the sources of revenue separately (goods, services, ancillary services) creates transparency and removes the basis for flat external comparisons.
Conclusion
Anyone who now invests in the quality of their internal data makes sure that the legally preferred method, the internal business comparison, becomes a shield and not a trap.
KANZLEI RUHLMANN in Berlin, with its specialisation in tax disputes, has extensive experience with estimates in tax audits. It supports clients in procedurally refuting unjustified official calculations and provides consistent tax representation in these proceedings.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. It does not replace individual legal advice.