Steering the compulsory portion stage-by-stage action safely: current case law on the information stage and cost risks

“My tactical advice for litigation: do not guess blindly when it comes to your compulsory portion. The decisive advantage of the stage-by-stage action is that it first lets you force the heir, through the court, to produce a complete estate inventory before you have to put a figure on the payment claim.”

Attorney Ruhlmann

Anyone who has been passed over in an inheritance knows the starting position: the claim to a compulsory portion often exists in principle, but the information about the estate, its liabilities and gifts lies with the heir. The stage-by-stage action (Stufenklage) opens the way to establishing these foundations and then putting a figure on the payment claim.

Drawing on recent case law, this article shows what matters in a well-targeted compulsory portion stage-by-stage action.

How the compulsory portion stage-by-stage action proceeds

A compulsory portion stage-by-stage action normally has three stages:

  • Information stage: The person entitled to a compulsory portion can demand information about the estate from the heir, and an estate inventory, under Section 2314 of the Civil Code (BGB).
  • Statutory declaration stage: If there are justified doubts about the completeness or correctness of the information, a statutory declaration under Section 260(2) BGB can be demanded at the second stage.
  • Performance stage: At the third stage, the claim to the compulsory portion, or to a supplementary compulsory portion, is quantified on the basis of the information given and payment is demanded.

The substantive basis: the information claim under Section 2314 BGB

Recent case law confirms and refines the established principles, particularly for the difficult information stage of the compulsory portion stage-by-stage action, which is still marked by considerable uncertainty. The information serves to clarify concrete facts that are relevant to the claim to the compulsory portion or the supplementary compulsory portion. German civil procedure, however, knows no general pre-litigation claim to information. Unlike Anglo-American “pre-trial discovery”, the compulsory portion stage-by-stage action does not give a free search for information against the opponent. Section 254 of the Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO) is merely the procedural vehicle; whether and to what extent information or valuation can be demanded is determined by substantive law.

Section 2314 BGB is decisive here: it governs the scope and subject of the information and valuation. Claimants who are entitled to a compulsory portion but are not heirs can demand information about the composition of the estate, an estate inventory and the valuation of individual items in the estate.

Typical mistakes in formulating the information request

The first stage of the compulsory portion stage-by-stage action stands or falls with a request tailored precisely to the substantive claim to information under Section 2314 BGB. Information, valuation, information on the notional estate and production of documents must be kept apart and matched to the specific compulsory portion claim.

Mistake no. 1: overlooking gifts in the supplementary compulsory portion
Anyone who merely demands information about the “composition of the estate” does not automatically capture the notional estate. That includes gifts that may be relevant to a supplementary compulsory portion claim under Section 2325 BGB. They must therefore be expressly included in the request for information: gifts to third parties normally for the last ten years before the death, gifts to the spouse in principle without this time limit. The claimant does not have to show specific indications of individual gifts for this. The information demanded must, however, be relevant to the compulsory portion; the stage-by-stage action does not open up a general probe into the deceased's finances.

Mistake no. 2: mixing up information and valuation
Information and valuation are separate subjects of the claim. A valuation requires that the item concerned is specifically identified and relevant to the claim to the compulsory portion or supplementary compulsory portion. As mentioned, it can also cover items that were given away and no longer belonged to the estate at the time of death. By contrast, a blanket expert report on the whole estate, or enquiries into the deceased's entire former assets, are not owed.

Example from case law (Higher Regional Court Hamm, judgment of 5 March 2026 – 10 U 78/25)
The deceased had given away a BMW motorcycle and a horse trailer; the heir did not know where the items were. He nevertheless had to make the appraisal possible and, if necessary, approach the present possessor. The case illustrates both points: gifts must be captured for the notional estate as far as they may matter for the supplementary compulsory portion; the valuation relates to the specifically identified items, not across the board to everything the deceased once owned.

Mistake no. 3: demanding documents across the board
Section 2314 BGB does not create a general duty to render accounts. Documents should therefore be demanded only specifically and in relation to the claim, such as land register documents for a particular property or documents on a particular shareholding in a limited company. A demand for “all account statements for the last ten years”, by contrast, can go too far.

Notarial estate inventory: the notary's own duty to investigate

In the information stage in particular, a notarial estate inventory makes sense if the claimant does not know the relevant assets and specific documents. It does not, however, replace a general probe into the estate.

The notary must carry out his own investigations, critically examine the heir's statements and use the sources of information that suggest themselves for the specific estate. This may include in particular inspecting account records if account balances or conspicuous account movements call for further investigation. How far and how deep the enquiries go depends on the circumstances of the individual case.

Example from case law (Higher Regional Court Düsseldorf, judgment of 24 January 2025 – 7 U 51/24)
Disinherited children demanded a notarial estate inventory from the deceased's partner, who had been appointed sole heir. The court held that a private estate inventory submitted by the heir does not in principle satisfy the claim to a notarial inventory. In that case there were considerable doubts about the completeness of the information given so far, because of unclarified assets and unexamined account statements. The decision underlines that a notarial inventory has independent significance precisely where there are such gaps in information.

In practice, it should therefore be checked whether the inventory takes proper account of the obvious documents and the unclarified assets. Specific gaps, such as unexplained sale proceeds, account movements or unclarified assets, can justify a request for supplementation. If, on the other hand, the inventory is complete but justified doubts about its completeness or correctness remain, a statutory declaration under Section 260(2) BGB comes into consideration.

Procedural strategy: suspension of limitation and cost risk

Within a stage-by-stage action, the information claim must always be assessed with a view to the intended performance stage: the information and payment applications must be factually connected, because the information must serve precisely the quantification of this payment claim. The choice and wording of the information stage must therefore already take account of the later performance stage, the amount in dispute and the cost risk that goes with it. In a genuine compulsory portion stage-by-stage action, the amount in dispute is fixed when the action is filed, on the basis of the payment expectation that can realistically and comprehensibly be assessed, even though the payment claim is not yet quantified. A lower figure at a later stage does not in principle lead automatically to the amount in dispute being corrected. Anyone who puts the expected compulsory portion clearly too high from the outset without sound indications therefore takes on a particular cost risk. The costs of a notarial estate inventory and of a justified valuation, on the other hand, are liabilities of the estate under Section 2314(2) BGB.

Example from case law (Higher Regional Court Munich, decision of 14 August 2023 – 33 W 321/23)
The court did not regard a payment expectation initially stated as €10,000 as realistic given a known valuable plot of land, after a figure of €265,000 later came into play.

The cost risk of a genuine stage-by-stage action must, where appropriate, be weighed against the risk of the payment claim becoming time-barred. A genuine stage-by-stage action in principle suspends limitation if the application for information is combined with an unquantified application for payment. If there is no limitation pressure and the value of a payment claim is completely uncertain, a stand-alone action for information can be the cheaper alternative. The choice between the two types of action therefore depends on the need for information, the limitation risk, the expected amount of the claim and the cost risk.

The move to the performance stage: demand for payment and cost control under Section 93 ZPO

Once sufficient information has been given, you should sue for the compulsory portion only when its amount can be calculated reliably. If the claimant then moves to the performance stage, Section 93 ZPO becomes relevant because of the cost consequences of an immediate acknowledgment. What matters is whether the heir had already given cause for the stage-by-stage action before it was filed. If he gave no cause and acknowledges the performance stage immediately, the claimant may have to bear the costs. If, on the other hand, the heir had already given cause for the stage-by-stage action, a fresh demand for payment is in principle not required before moving to the performance stage.

Cost control therefore depends not only on the amount of the claim but also on what happened beforehand and on a realistic quantification. The amount should be calculated carefully and the heir expressly asked to pay within a reasonable deadline. Default interest should be claimed from the relevant start of default; the demand for payment and further correspondence should be fully documented.

Example from case law (Higher Regional Court Braunschweig, decision of 21 February 2025 – 10 W 1/25)
The court had to decide a case in which the defendant had acknowledged the claim to the compulsory portion and to information in principle. A deadline extension she had requested for providing the information, however, had passed without result, so that she was in default with the information. She paid €25,000 only on the day the stage-by-stage action was served. The claimant had therefore had cause to bring the action. The costs could not be imposed on him under Section 93 ZPO despite the payment and although he did not continue the proceedings to the performance stage. The case shows that what happened before the action was filed is decisive for the decision on costs.

Conclusion

The compulsory portion stage-by-stage action is neither a standard form nor a general tool for probing. It requires careful coordination of information, valuation, performance stage and cost risk. Used in a targeted way, it remains an effective instrument for preparing and enforcing claims to a compulsory portion and a supplementary compulsory portion.

In inheritance disputes, KANZLEI RUHLMANN in Berlin represents you as a litigation firm for inheritance law – out of court where possible, resolutely in court where necessary.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. It does not replace individual legal advice.