Federal Court of Justice: actions for information and stage-by-stage actions are admissible for dissolved partnerships

A typical mistake after the dissolution of a partnership is to sue directly for payment or compensation; this regularly fails because of the so-called enforcement bar (Durchsetzungssperre).

The Federal Court of Justice, however, allows a stage-by-stage action (Stufenklage) in which, at the performance stage (instead of payment), the claimant seeks only a declaration of the accounting items. This saves the detour through several lawsuits.

Attorney Ruhlmann

The enforcement bar in dissolved partnerships

In a shareholder dispute after a partnership has failed – through termination, a falling-out or the completion of a joint project, for example – the question often arises: who still has to pay whom? In a dissolved civil-law partnership (GbR), general partnership (OHG), limited partnership (KG) or professional partnership, this can normally not be settled with a stand-alone payment action. A comprehensive overall settlement is required first; this is known as the company-law enforcement bar. That does not leave the partner without legal protection, however: first the information needed for the settlement must be obtained, and the claim can then be quantified.

Action for information and accounting, or stage-by-stage action

If the partner lacks the information needed for the settlement, he can demand it by a stand-alone action for information or accounting. Alternatively, he can bring a stage-by-stage action under Section 254 of the Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO). This normally proceeds in three steps: first, information and, where applicable, accounts are demanded. If necessary, the correctness and completeness of the information can then be confirmed by a statutory declaration. After that, the claim is quantified on the basis of the information obtained and pursued as a performance claim, usually a claim for payment.

An action for information despite the enforcement bar in a dispute between partners

Where the enforcement bar applies, it is precisely this payment claim that is normally not yet possible. That does not mean the partner has to wait: information and, where applicable, accounts can be enforced in court in order to clarify the open items for the settlement account. The Federal Court of Justice has confirmed that the enforcement bar does not prevent such an action for information in the form of a stage-by-stage action (Federal Court of Justice, decision of 8 July 2025 – II ZB 1/25).

Once the information has been given, it may be clear how much an individual claim is worth. Because of the enforcement bar, however, it still cannot in principle be demanded as a stand-alone payment. The settlement account as a whole must first show who can claim which balance at the end. Direct payment is possible only exceptionally, for example if the partner is certain to be owed at least a certain amount or if no partnership assets remain to be wound up.

A declaratory action instead of a stand-alone payment action

If the enforcement bar continues to apply and this is not an exceptional case, a stand-alone payment action is in principle not possible. Instead, the claimant should expressly apply for a declaration that the quantified item is to be included as an accounting item in the settlement account. The Federal Court of Justice has now confirmed this route again (see Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 16 June 2026 – II ZR 85/25). According to case law, a premature payment claim may possibly be interpreted accordingly, but one should not rely on that.

A declaratory judgment is, however, not a title for payment and replaces neither the overall settlement nor the determination of the settlement balance. If payment is not made once the settlement is complete, a separate action for payment of the settlement balance is in principle needed. This can trigger court and legal costs again. The declaratory judgment nevertheless eases the proceedings, because the accounting item is conclusively clarified and can no longer be disputed as to its basis or the amount determined.

Conclusion: the right way to sue where an enforcement bar applies

In dissolved partnerships, the overall settlement is in principle what counts first because of the enforcement bar. If the information needed for it is missing, the partner can demand information and, where applicable, accounts in a stand-alone action or by way of a stage-by-stage action. Within the stage-by-stage action, once information or accounts have been given and the enforcement bar still applies, the claimant should normally apply not for payment but for a declaration that the now quantified item is to be included as an accounting item in the settlement account. If the item can be quantified from the start, no action for information or stage-by-stage action is needed; the declaratory action can be brought directly. An action for payment, by contrast, is normally possible only once the settlement balance has been determined.

In shareholder disputes and the winding-up of partnerships, KANZLEI RUHLMANN in Berlin represents you as a litigation firm for commercial and company law – out of court where possible, resolutely in court where necessary.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. It does not replace individual legal advice.