Federal Court of Justice ruling on avoidance of tax payments in sham transactions becomes a liability trap for managing directors

In cases of sham transactions, the Federal Court of Justice has opened a narrow but dangerous evidential window: if tax payments are successfully avoided, the tax debts revive. The tax office can then recover these shortfalls directly from the managing director's private assets through officer liability (Section 69 of the Fiscal Code).

Attorney Marcel Ruhlmann (specialist tax lawyer)

The Federal Court of Justice judgment of 31 July 2025 (IX ZR 32/24)

In its judgment of 31 July 2025 (IX ZR 32/24), the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) for the first time expressly opened insolvency avoidance against the tax authorities even where final and binding tax assessments or the debtor's own tax returns underlie the payment, but only in a narrowly limited exceptional category: cases in which the debtor, through his own conduct, “created” a tax liability that is obviously, and beyond serious doubt, incorrect. The Federal Court of Justice thus does not break the principle of protection against avoidance in general, but opens a new, narrow “evidential window”.

The principle remains: payments on tax assessments or tax returns are as a rule made “for consideration”, because they discharge a debt, and a materially incorrect assessment does not change this. They therefore cannot be avoided as gifts (Section 134 of the Insolvency Code). What is new is the clear exception for evidential cases: if a return or assessment goes beyond the range of normal factual or legal uncertainty and the debtor contributed to it, the resulting liability is exceptionally treated as “gratuitous”, and the payment can be avoided.

This is particularly clear with payroll tax. If genuine employment relationships exist, payroll tax arises when wages are paid; paying it over fulfils the employer's own duty and in principle remains unavoidable. If, on the other hand, there are only sham employment relationships – for example where “employment contracts” were concluded as a sham and no work is actually done –, materially no payroll tax arises. If the debtor nevertheless declares and pays it, the payment can be avoided as a gratuitous benefit if it is established that the sham was obvious.

The standard does not apply only to payroll tax. There are typical constellations with VAT too. The decision addresses, for example, a “precautionary” reverse-charge declaration, in which VAT was declared and paid “as a precaution” under the reverse-charge procedure although it was objectively recognisable that a domestic entrepreneur, not a foreign one, had made the supply. Chain models with “sham” supply runs (VAT carousels) would surely be assessed in the same way: if declarations or payments are based on constellations in which the “supplying entrepreneur” recognisably does not exist or does not supply (straw man, no registered office), payments on such declarations would be avoidable under this new line of case law, where the incorrectness is obvious.

For the practice of insolvency administrators (and debtors in self-administration), this means that since this decision tax payments made in recent years are examined specifically for such evidential cases. What matters is whether the departure from the legal position was objectively obvious and was co-caused by the debtor's conduct; only then does the new avoidance window apply. In the immediate aftermath of this decision, practice already shows insolvency administrators reclaiming tax payments on a large scale and examining existing proceedings intensively.

A practical note: the liability trap for the managing director

When the insolvency administrator successfully reclaims a payment, it sets off a damaging chain reaction: through the avoidance, the company's tax debt revives retroactively. Since the company is insolvent, the tax office holds the managing director personally liable by a liability notice under Sections 34 and 69 of the Fiscal Code. The tax authorities' argument is that initiating or tolerating sham transactions is an intentional breach of tax duties. Although the managing director paid the taxes over punctually at the time, he is now liable retroactively with all of his private assets.

Many managing directors in this position stay passive in the insolvency proceedings, because they want to leave their defence to the later liability proceedings. That is a fatal mistake: if the revived tax claim is entered on the schedule without objection, the preclusive effect of Section 166 of the Fiscal Code cuts off any defence on the merits in the later proceedings. Managing directors must therefore use their own right of objection under Section 176(2) of the Insolvency Code at the examination meeting. Even if the tax claim may be justified arithmetically, only a timely objection prevents this binding effect. It forces the tax office, in the liability proceedings, to prove separately the managing director's personal fault in relation to the later avoidability.

At precisely this complex interface, KANZLEI RUHLMANN offers decisive support from Berlin. With deep specialisation in both insolvency law and tax law, the firm provides coordinated defence advice in insolvency and tax proceedings, in order to block existence-threatening liability risks proactively.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. It does not replace individual legal advice.