Loss of goods in air transport: Higher Regional Court Düsseldorf, judgment of 21 January 2026, on the chain of custody and liability
“Unclear handover points in transport quickly become expensive liability traps in court.”
Attorney Ruhlmann
In transport law, liability for lost goods depends decisively on who had the consignment in their custody at what time, and on which liability regime applies.
Anyone who cannot prove when custody changed hands, and who was responsible among the third parties involved, risks being unable to rely later on a more favourable liability regime or a limit on liability. For carriers, a traceable record of the transport is therefore key evidence. This is shown by the decision of the Higher Regional Court (OLG) Düsseldorf, judgment of 21 January 2026 – 18 U 155/24.
Facts
The case concerned the partial loss of mobile phones from transported parcels. A cargo insurer, acting under subrogated rights, claimed against the defendant for this partial loss. The consignment was carried by air via Cluj and Bucharest to Chișinău.
At Chișinău airport, the defendant air carrier had no facility of its own. According to its submission, a ground-handling company, which it had neither instructed nor controlled, loaded the parcels onto a truck after unloading. Damaged parcels and shortages were found only at the defendant's transshipment centre.
The decisive question was therefore not only where the parcels physically were, but whether they were still legally in the air carrier's custody.
The decision: custody determines the applicable liability law
The court had to decide whether the Montreal Convention (MC) or German freight law governed the partial loss. The defendant relied on the MC, while the claimant asserted liability under German freight law. Applying the MC would in principle have been more favourable for the defendant, because it sets a liability ceiling. Under Article 18(3) MC, however, the Convention applies only to damage occurring while the goods are in the legal custody of the air carrier. The mere presence of the consignment on the airport grounds, or an actual handling operation, is not enough.
Because it knew far more about its own transport processes, the defendant bore a secondary burden of presentation. Its general statements about the process and the ground-handling company were not sufficient. It would have had to say specifically who took over the parcels after unloading, on what basis that person or company acted, and what control and access rights the defendant itself retained. Since it did not do so sufficiently, the court could proceed on the claimant's version, under which the consignment was no longer in the defendant's custody at the relevant time.
It could therefore not be assumed that the partial loss occurred while the goods were in the defendant's custody as air carrier. The Montreal Convention and its limit on liability did not apply. Sections 425(1) and 452 of the German Commercial Code (HGB) applied instead. The court also found qualified fault under Section 435 HGB: the defendant had left the consignment with an unknown and uncontrolled third party although a considerable loss was foreseeable. For that reason, the limit on liability under Section 431 HGB fell away as well. The defendant was therefore liable without limit for the partial loss.
In practice for carriers: documenting the chain of custody so that it stands up as evidence
If the claimant cannot know how the transport went, the carrier bears a secondary burden of presentation. It must explain the chain of custody specifically: in particular who took over the consignment and when, which handovers, scans and accesses are documented, and which persons or companies were responsible. General references to usual airport procedures, customs supervision or unknown third parties are not enough.
Conclusion
The Düsseldorf decision shows that anyone who hands custody of a consignment to an unknown and uncontrolled third party risks far-reaching liability. In this case the court applied German freight law, found qualified fault under Section 435 HGB and therefore let the limit on liability under Section 431 HGB fall away. For carriers, a controlled chain of custody with gap-free documentation is therefore a central part of risk management.
Where air freight is lost in particular, you need to act extremely fast and with legal care because of the short cut-off and notification periods (for example under the Warsaw Convention or the Montreal Convention).
For liability questions, transport damage or payment claims under freight contracts, KANZLEI RUHLMANN in Berlin represents you as a litigation firm for transport law, resolutely before the competent chambers.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. It does not replace individual legal advice.